Regarding Roger’s talk on Dingle

[greenscience9000]

Underdetermination in relativity

Conversation with Brave AI reconstruction via Deepseek AI: # Dingle Paradox for Relativity – Cleaned Conversation ## User: Dingle Paradox for Relativity **Brave AI:** The Dingle Paradox (or Dingle’s Clock Paradox) was an argument advanced by British astrophysicist Herbert Dingle (1890–1978) claiming Einstein’s Special Theory of Relativity (STR) is logically self-contradictory. ### Core argument Two clocks in relative motion each see the other as slower → “If A works more slowly than B, then…